Letters
    Next Score View the next score

    Letters

    Title IX directive was put in place to correct lapses in school policies

    As US Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos collects information to replace the 2011 Title IX guidance issued to colleges, it is important that she seek the perspectives of organizations experienced in best practices developed over decades of direct service work with survivors (“Revise — but don’t revoke — sex assault policy,” Editorial, Sept. 9).

    The first thing these organizations will insist on is procedural justice for student survivors. This is the simple act of taking sexual violence complaints seriously and implementing transparent response policies and protocols. Over the past seven years, thanks to the 2011 Title IX guidance, many schools have done this. Indeed, it was the lack of such procedural justice that led to the Title IX guidance in the first place.

    The second thing these organizations will do is remind all parties involved that it would be a mistake to insist on integrating the criminal justice system into educational institutions’ adjudication process. A 2015 survey of more than 150,000 students by the Association of American Universities found that incapacitation due to alcohol or drugs was a factor in a “significant percentage” of sexual assaults on campus. In such cases, the physical evidence required for prosecution is almost never present.

    Advertisement

    In addition, in most of these cases, the students involved know each other. They may live in the same dorm or attend the same classes. The ability of student survivors to remain fully engaged in their education, and safe within their campus community, does not often require the involvement of law enforcement. Those needs can frequently be met with a new dorm assignment or accommodations in class. Under Title IX, colleges are required to provide a “prompt and equitable resolution” of complaints.

    Get Arguable in your inbox:
    Jeff Jacoby on everything from politics to pet peeves to the passions of the day.
    Thank you for signing up! Sign up for more newsletters here

    Finally, as comments are collected, it is important that those representing the students who’ve had a sexual assault complaint filed against them are legitimate practitioners with experience litigating, arbitrating, and hearing campus sexual assault cases, and not ideologically driven men’s rights activists.

    Stephanie DeCandia

    Director of programs

    The Boston Area Rape Crisis Center

    Cambridge